I'm hoping that maybe, since I haven't insulted or attacked him, he'll actually engage with me. Doesn't look like it so far, but we'll see.
Asthmo, if you'd prefer to have this conversation over a beer, I'll buy the first round. Serious. Just you and me, no other BARFers have to come. Especially not Roman, there'd be no alcohol left for us if he came

.
Corb, the psychological "test" (it's not much of one really) is the only real difference officers have compared to the general public who carry with a permit. And I'm trying to keep this discussion relevant to at least California if not the bay area, since that's how it started - people here who have friends in the bay area who carry at home. If we start branching out into Arizona, Texas, Alaska, etc sooner or later people start bringing up Switzerland, Israel, etc and by that point we're not even comparing apples to oranges we're comparing apples to the architectural styles of ancient Rome and shit.
As for regularly tested for substance abuse...hah, sometimes. Rarely. And if they pop hot it's not like their gun gets taken away. Also not really relevant if they're not carrying under the influence. While I don't smoke personally and am not the biggest fan of weed, I know plenty of people who smoke regularly and are perfectly functional and responsible when they're not smoking. But would still pop hot on a piss test in a heartbeat.
Corb, you're also not the only one here who's seen war, who's seen "what guns do to people" as a child, etc. While I can appreciate the effect it has on your opinion, I'd like to think we can agree that these things affect everyone differently.
Anyway, I'm waiting on Asthmo's response if he'll give one.