What do you shutdown ambassadors do for a living? I'm envious of your shutdown until there is a cure position. Does the federal debt load matching our annual GDP not factor at ALL into your view of the world? Does the looming layoff cliff not concern you in the least? Imploding industries don't give you pause to think maybe there is a middle ground? With a few exceptions this place is so caught up in the prevailing group think that critical thinking skills have been tabled for the sake of flaming anyone with a differing, perhaps broader view of a path forward.
When you get right down to it, this is what the whole difference of opinion(s) is really about, isn’t it?
If you’re able to work from home, or already retired and don’t need to work, you have the luxury of believing the science that supports a general shutdown in order to bring the pandemic to heel. And you’ll be able to continue working and earning your living and paying your bills, although your spend on vacations and restaurant meals may be greatly curtailed. (Bummer).
If, on the other hand, you own a business or work for one that cannot function under lockdown, and therefore your ability to make ends meet is cut, then obviously you’re going to subscribe to messaging and the alternative narrative that supports the notion of letting things roll and aiming for herd immunity sooner than later.
Around the world different countries have taken a variety of different approaches. In some countries (those, you know, horrible socialist ones), they have always had a public safety net in place that provides for people who can’t work and need financial assistance. So restaurant and retail shop workers are continuing to get at least a portion of their regular wages so they can continue to pay the rent and buy groceries.
Other countries (Sweden for instance) initially took the herd immunity approach, and more recently have accepted that that ended up not working out so well.
Regardless of approach, I think it’s important to separate out the scientific and medical reality of what’s happening from the social/political decisions and fallout.
The reality is that this isn’t the flu. All one has to do is see the stealth YouTube videos of healthcare workers in hospitals, or pictures of the makeshift refrigerated truck morgues in hospital parking lots, or the temporary infirmaries built from tents at San Quentin on the baseball field to realize that this isn’t like anything anyone has ever seen before. You don’t do those things for the flu. Period.
After that, the challenge becomes a bit of a dilemma, particularly for those who back the current administration. Do they accept the “there’s no problem here - it’s over folks” story, and endorse going back to work right now? See previous paragraph - refrigerated truck morgues. Or do they endorse a continuation of workers comp relief checks to help those who can’t work make ends meet? See previous paragraph - the evil socialism!
It’s a bit of an ideological pickle, I’d say, for some. Doesn’t diminish the real pain and suffering that so many households are living through right now. Does make me wonder, though, whether now might be a good time to reconsider what all the options are; and which ones make the most sense for everyone.