I am selling my F800GS and considering an SM-T or an FJ-09. As you currently have both... what is your take?
Heh, I get this question a lot.
The SMT and FJ-09 are both great bikes in their own right. It comes down to motor preference. 90% of my riding career has been on triples, so I am most comfortable on them.
The SMT has
significantly better suspension and brakes—an area where I'm about to drop nearly $3k on the FJ to get it in the same ballpark of the SMT. Don't get me wrong, I am by no means a suspension snob. The FJ is a budget bike and suspension and brakes are the areas that it's obvious. I'm reminded of this every time I throw a leg over and take off. The longer travel suspension and greater ground clearance of the SMT gives me greater confidence on the goaty stuff.
The FJ is pretty fun, but I was looking for an appliance bike when I bought the FJ. I almost regret it as total price with the mods and such to get it on the same level of the SMT is close to $15k. The SMT is better set up for sport touring, in my opinion. Range on both (with my riding style) is about ~150, but the SMT's bags are incredibly handy—something that is another $1k-$2k on the FJ.
I modded
this SMT to address all the annoying quirks that the FJ would have a lead on—fueling, reliability, HP, tour-ability, etc.
If I wasn't as comfortable with the triple, I'd absolutely be selling the FJ instead of the KTM and her V-Twin. As I mentioned before, I think it comes down to motor preference.
Hope that helps!