• There has been a recent cluster of spammers accessing BARFer accounts and posting spam. To safeguard your account, please consider changing your password. It would be even better to take the additional step of enabling 2 Factor Authentication (2FA) on your BARF account. Read more here.

Thoughts on AWD cars?

Probably more than you, flatlander. You didn't say "pure black ice", you just said ice. I call bullshit. Since you know... I've been there, done that.

So where have you lived? I spent 33 years in Michigan and Colorado, 13 of them as a driver. How about you? And what did you THINK I meant when I said ice? If I meant to say something else like "packed snow", I would have said so.

You don't even know about different types of ice. :laughing How sweet. :laughing

:wtf :rolleyes


A FWD with a good traction control system can keep you out of snow banks almost as well as AWD.

I was looking at a used VW R32 vs a New '14 Jetta TDI- I decided I'd rather have the 42- 50 MPG option over AWD, plus it will make the Tahoe trips cheaper.

... Why Jetta... are you a college girl?!?!? Santa Barbara???? Changing aliases frequently???? ;) :laughing What's with Jettas and women.. anyways. And then men too.

Also can anybody tell me how a "FWD with a good traction control" will help you when one wheel is already *in* the bank. Doesn't it freewheel? Or did they change that on modern cars
 
I'm surprised you had ice in Michigan. Minnesota doesn't fuck around; Fall typically lasted for a single week, and then we went straight from decent weather to frozen tundra. Ice never happened - it was almost always too quick of a transition straight into snow.

Snow driving on the other hand... Some of the best years of my life ;) Absolute riot, if approached with the right attitude.
Michigan gets the lake effect, Minnesota air is drier to my knowledge. And the thing about lower Michigan is that the temps aren't that severe, they're usually hovering around freezing, going back and forth, so snow on the road melts and re-freezes constantly. Plus they get lots of freezing rain.

Snow, yes, it's a blast, I regularly blew away Exploders and Broncos in my 79 Rabbit with snow tires and a couple bags of cement in the back. I love the clowns who think that just because they have 4WD they can do anything with their wide-ass summer tires still on. :rofl
 
Last edited:
Also can anybody tell me how a "FWD with a good traction control" will help you when one wheel is already *in* the bank. Doesn't it freewheel? Or did they change that on modern cars

The simple, get-out-of-a-ditch traction control system based solution is to detect the disproportionate wheelspin and apply brake pressure to that wheel which will redistribute torque to the other wheel(s).
 
haha! SNOW BALL (ing)

I feel like I'm reading another "OMFG 250's RULE EVERY OTHER BIKE" thread...

But you're a California transplant from PA, what could you possibly know about snowballing? :loco
 
haha! SNOW BALL (ing)

I feel like I'm reading another "OMFG 250's RULE EVERY OTHER BIKE" thread...

Well shit... If we're headed down that path, then I'm going to resume posting Volvo content, because I'm pretty sure they're the best cars of all time.

May I submit for evidence this video...

[youtube]M6FCid97yBg[/youtube]
 
haha! SNOW BALL (ing)

I feel like I'm reading another "OMFG 250's RULE EVERY OTHER BIKE" thread...

Lol how this thread has seemed to take a turn for 'who has the bigger penis'. Can't a girl just like how her little Scooby handles and wants to know what else might be out there that has moar power and excellent handling?
 
True Ken...we NEVER get those there! BTW, I'm a CA transplant to PA and then back to CA!

And we make a good amount of money back there thanks to that snow and ice! So keep it coming!
 
True Ken...we NEVER get those there! BTW, I'm a CA transplant to PA and then back to CA!

And we make a good amount of money back there thanks to that snow and ice! So keep it coming!

:rofl:rofl:rofl

We got three feet of snow in NV in 48 hrs and the locals called it a blizzard. I was rolling. To me a blizzard is when you have to exit from the second story of the house and have to spend 4-8 hours digging the driveway out with a snow shovel to get the vehicle to the road (and hopefully it has been plowed by then.) Yeah- you don't know snow!:twofinger:cool

I'm a PA/Philly native transplanted to CA and back...
 
Where I'm from everything is better or worse or more extreme than where ever you're from! We're totally hardcore badasses from where I'm from, you don't even know what you're talking about!! Smily face, smily face to show I'm just poking fun but really you're all a bunch of pussies compared to the people who are from where I'm from!

Get an AWD if that's what you want and be happy with it.
 
:rofl:rofl:rofl

We got three feet of snow in NV in 48 hrs and the locals called it a blizzard. I was rolling. To me a blizzard is when you have to exit from the second story of the house and have to spend 4-8 hours digging the driveway out with a snow shovel to get the vehicle to the road (and hopefully it has been plowed by then.) Yeah- you don't know snow!:twofinger:cool

I'm a PA/Philly native transplanted to CA and back...


Don't ya just hate it though..When Ya shovel down to your driveway to open the door to get the snow blower out, and clear your driveway, and as you walk back to get the car..The plow comes by, and puts up a new solid wall?
 
I have had a heavily modified 450HP Mitsubishi 3000 GT AWD Turbo since 1994 and have thrashed it every one of its 134,000 miles.

I picked up a brand new EVO IX MR in '06, wound the wick up to 420 HP and have wrung its neck also for 87,000 miles.

Both cars have been utterly reliable and absolutely brilliant in all conditions and on track.

After spending almost 20 years driving high HP AWD cars hard, I don't think I would be safe in a 2WD car anymore :laughing

i think it's important you mention this as most people have no idea how robust the evo platform is. i daily drove a highly prepared street car that passed modified ZO6s not only in the corners but also on the straightaway where there was no skill, only power involved.

track activites: bounce off of the limiter regularly, boil the brake fluid, on track temps of 120, annihilating pure race cars with my AC on max, on dot legal r-comps (great all around tires, but not nearly as good as the michelin blues + aerodynamics packages others were using).

track work + commute to work, at one point i was on pace to hit 35,000 miles annually on that car. that said, didn't have to do anything other than consumables - oil, brakes, tires.

of course, when using expensive consumables at an obscene pace, i learned how to do the majority of my work on my own. including data logging (engine paramaters, AFR data), interpretation of data leading to learning how to do actual tuning (including alternate fuels), and a seperate system to log and analyze telemetry. that's when you really learn just how simple it is to work on an evo (vs the stupid flat boxer motor, with twice the components, smaller access areas, and an intercooler mounted at the hottest point in the engine bay), and how idiot proof the engineers at mitsubishi made the drivetrain (it's incredible: the car comes rich from the factory, and an aftermarket intake and exhaust set the AFRs almost exactly right - evidence that they knew exactly who would buy this car and what they would do first) and how effective it is when you start to look at even simple 0-60, 1/4 and trap speeds, and continuous and maximum transient g loading.

Ha then they were not trying hard enough or they were in the wrong AWD car.

There is a reason that the SCCA banned Audi AWD's and Mitsubishi Eclips AWD's from racing back in the late 80's and 90's - they absolutely spanked all the far more expensive 911's and GT1 specials. The 911 owners all all of the SCCA's GT1 Class objected, so AWD's were banned for 20 years.

The whole point of high performance AWD cars is that they have unbelievable dynamics at the limit. Mitsubishi's EVO IX FQ 420 petty much set the benchmark for real world road and track performance when it was put up against pretty much everything else, over and over again.

The feature that really stands out was that any test driver could get consistent 10/10th lap times out of the EVO because it was so forgiving at the limit, whereas only one or two test drivers could get the best out of 911's, Corvettes and equivalent 2WD cars.

it always struck me that reviewers would talk about all the tech in the evo. electronic yaw control, electronic center diff, etc. when people talk too much about that, i know they don't have much time in the evo at high speed or really dynamic scenarios. that's when the systems really show how refined, effective, and complimentary they are. these aren't lunky MB traction controls, with slow actuation and even slower recovery.

the only other car that i have found to be as intuitive to drive is the E30 M3. which is, in my opinion, the only M3 that matters. and yes, i had one of those too, with the track time and mountain time to speak from experience. that is the only other sports car i would consider at the moment, but i dont have the garage space for it.

But why? You had it correct the first time; the Cobalt SS is better stock than both those cars AND FWD...unless you must have AWD. Here's my experience at the track with AWD: the guys in the Subi's and Evo's spun more than anything out there, unless it was raining...and then they would merely depart the track. I'm not blaming the car, but I AM blaming the apparent lack of grip due to these AWD jockey's not understanding weight shift and contact patch when they turned in early and matted the throttle, expecting the AWD system to fix ALL of their errors. AWD is also more wear on tires, drivetrain, fuel economy, etc...but it IS nice in the snow/ slick.

A good Cobalt SS can be had for about $12K. $12K and you get a hell of a lot of car. Then go get a Subaru Outback wagon for $10K and use that for ski trips...IMO of course.

the thing about good drivers is they are good especially when the conditions are bad. when the conditions are good, and someone does weak shit, that's a personal failing.

that said, awd systems are insensitive to environmental conditions relative to a fwr or rwd setup. this can help compensate for people that don't like rain or snow. personally, i relish those conditions. rainy winter days are among my favorite training conditions on the supermoto. but in exactly 0 conditions are a fwd dynamically superior to the other two. but, fwd can be very fun to drive nonetheless. if fwd gives you a secure feeling and lets you drive more confidently, and ultimately have more fun, then go for it. but i wouldn't minimize just how much more fun rwd or awd is over fwd.

Owners of Evo's are the WORST in terms of taking care of the things...the ones I see at auction are beat to shit under the wheel wells. Without a doubt, one of the worst owners cars, IME. Cobalts are actually well cared for (most) as they're Chevy brand loyalists who own and wax the shit of these things...but that's a pretty general statement. There are those who beat on the things...

BTW, 16-23 years olds are not the ones who beat on their cars. It's not limited to age...it's really unlimited and you never know who's beat on what till you own it. Sucks...

Boring...yeah, nothing ground shaking. But they own at the track and with a few mods, REALLY own at the track...for cheap.

generally speaking, this is very true for evos. people run them hard. they invite you to. i've said several times that the evo is incredibly robust. but as with any sports car, buyer beware.

I totally disagree with that. I owned an evo and im 21 and my insurance was around 150 a month for full coverage

do you have any real adults on your policy in addition or are you the only one? once we added my father in law to our policy, we got like a 40% discount. free pro-tip for those of you out there with cars in the expensive insurance bracket.

Lol how this thread has seemed to take a turn for 'who has the bigger penis'. Can't a girl just like how her little Scooby handles and wants to know what else might be out there that has moar power and excellent handling?

well, i'm running out of suggestions at this point.
-i read a bit more the last few days about the raliart, and the reviews suggested that the lancer ralliart sportback is actually dynamically sharper than the wrx, with a little less cargo room. but that might not be the case against the latest generation of wrx.
-wrx, focus st, MS3 are good contenders, but awd eliminates the last two. which circles back to the ralliart sportback.
-the SUV/CUV segment might be interesting to you. i rather like the outlander for its combination of a class leading (for my taste) awd system that is pretty dang fun in light duty off roading and pretty nice on-raod, with a tailgate, 7 seats, and a smaller footprint than lets say a pickup truck. the engine choices are below average for the segment, especially vs the latest crop of SUVs (nvh is bleh, mpg is below average, low on power) but, again, i was oddly excited when i was OFOing in the dirt in the outlander gt.
-another thought would be a suby forester with the turbo'd motor. a bit of gound clearance, awd, cargo, etc. amazing that no one had suggested that yet. should also be acceptable insurance. just understand that everyone will assume you're a lesbian.
 
Last edited:
Ok, too many pages to read.

I have a 2007 WRX wagon. Bought it new, went through a buyback lawsuit with it in the first year because of a simple ac problem that the techs were too lazy to properly diag. (I was a master certified Mercedes tech and assistant foreman for many years so I am qualified to say that). I got a bunch of money back on it. I have only gone to one subie dealer out of six that hasn't either damaged something, failed to fix something, or left something loose. I was really hoping not to work on my own car after working on cars all day, but that's life.
Other than the ac issue the car has been pretty resilient to my weekend thrashings up to the mountains at stupid speed when I was regularly racing MTB and ski instructing. It has been a magnet for idiot drivers and has been hit a number of times. Lucky all cosmetic damage and nothing structural. It's always gone to the body shops that my shop sends all the Benz repairs to so the quality is spot on, but I digress.

Having only seen the Evo's and not driven one, I can't attest to a comparison of driving quality. But the fit and finish of the Subie has been superior, and I am picky.

The subie does understeer unless you flick it into corners. It was a total surprise on my first run up to Big Bear, but once I got used to adjusting my steering input it has been excellent. The stock tires were adequate and had predictable drift. I switched to Michelin pilot sport AS3 and got a ton more grip. So much so that it changed the handling and actually spits the front end inside on the corners a bit at corner exits when the suspension unloads. No, the suspension and alignment are spot on, it's just an effect of more grip and G loading resulting in more rebound.

I have heard the 5 speeds were fragile, but the six speeds had a host of issues with 6th gear and reverse as well. The interior noise is barely acceptable, and has improved with the tire change. The motor is a pain to do major services, but I do like having the low center of gravity and the inline style drive line. The 2008+ subies are a different beast, aside from looking like a kia. The first gen traction control was clunky and distracting. The hillstart assist did more to stall you than assist you. I could kick my buddies arse around corners going head to head with my 07 wrx wagon against his 08 wrx sedan. And he was a good driver and experienced in autocross. I hope the newer ones have become more refined over the years.

From the German side of things, there are some great cars built like panzer tanks that handle like a dream at high speeds. But don't own one out of warranty, and expect to put brake pads on every 15k, rotors every 30k, and tires at 20k. All that weight and the impressive handling detract from the longevity of wear items. They are very safe and tires and brakes are a small price to pay for walking away from a nasty accident. After years of seeing wrecks in the shop I am convinced there is no better car to be in during an accident than a Benz.

It's your cash, your preference, and your arse on the line when stuff hits the fan. Pick up on the facts and take the opinions with a grain of salt. good luck with the new ride whatever it is.
 
You guys are all too hardcore. Lexus IS250 AWD. Not the fastest or the best up the hill but they sure are comfy and look good too. Here's one for 27k.
 
Well, she did ask for something a bit quicker than her current car.
 
Don't ya just hate it though..When Ya shovel down to your driveway to open the door to get the snow blower out, and clear your driveway, and as you walk back to get the car..The plow comes by, and puts up a new solid wall?

Been there done that- it is the suck!:mad
 
Back
Top