11 or 12-ish years ago I was visiting my dad in PA and left stuff in the car (camera, wallet, GPS, etc). Came out the next morning to go somewhere and just down the road I realized my GPS was missing, went back to see if I'd taken it in the previous night then called the cops. My CU told me my card had been used at a local grocery store, cops went there, looked at security tapes, ID'd the suspects and arrested them (dude and his GF, in their early 20s) that afternoon.
They had ripped off several people in a big circular route from where they were living at the time, just down the road from my dad, semi-rural area. They ended up going to jail and being ordered to pay restitution. this happened in 2011 or 2012 and I still get status updates (parole or probation or whatever) and restitution checks from the DA. The last one I remember was in April or May for $15-20. The town where he lives has just over 1,000 people and the county has 450,000 or something so it's not an apples-to-apples comparison, but I'm not sure the cops in my town would do anything in a similar incident or that the DA would prosecute.