i would never recommend any type of shoes marketed as 'riding shoes'...only benefit may be a top cover for shifting and thicker sole for the pegs but not much protection otherwise ...just for comfort when you get to your destination but not much while riding...
the ideal of these types of shoes is to get the name out there to the general public and not only for the riding community...marketed to start a trend rather than function...good example is fox gear...
they also don't have proper fit where i've seen these shoes slip off at a 30mph mishap....
the most minimum would be something like this...while cumbersome to change to regular shoes, not worth the risk of injury on the long run...