X, Natural Gas (furnace and new water heater), 429kwh
Gas portion was $620
We may have a problem with our new water heater - complained to AO Smith about the very hot water even on a low setting - a plumber comes out on Monday.
Previous years the most was ~ $375 total utility bill during the winter time though and we are not living any differently
Your electric sounds good, but that gas sure sucks. If you averaged $2.60/g, you'd be using about 240g/mo? We have propane and run the furnace every morning to get the house up to temp for a bit, then leave it off most of the day and use the fireplace at night. Doing that in the winter months, our 500g tank will drop 10-12% per month, or about 50-60g. We paid $2.38/g at the last refill in October, so that's about $119-$143/mo. Oh, we also have other propane appliances; range/oven, 50g tank water heater, and clothes dryer, so that's included in the total use (household of three people).
I'd say we use the furnace sparingly since the fireplace takes over at night, but it's also a lot colder here at 4k feet elevation, sometimes in the teens and often in the twenties, plus we have this damned dog door in the slider that drives me nuts with how much heat we lose through it. I'm not sure if this is enough to make it a wash with being in the bay, but it's something to mention.
The propane guys tell us that the furnace is the huge suck and everything else is negligible, which jives with my experience because we hardly use any gas outside of the cold months. If it were May and our tank were at 20%, there's no problem making it to October or November for the next refill with normal use of everything aside from the furnace. If our gas worked out to $620/mo, I'd be trying to supplement with electricity, like if you left the furnace on all night, then maybe turn it off and use a space heater for the bedroom/s overnight, that kind of thing. Then you're really only looking at using the furnace from when you get home, to bedtime, then whatever on weekends.
And then if the electricity becomes a problem, look into having your baseline changed. You're probably on basic, which is only 10.9kwh/day in territory X durign winter, but it'd be bumped up to 16.7kwh/day if you told PGE a small fib that you had electric as your main heat source and you only supplement with gas.