He sure paints with a broad brush doesn’t he? As has been said many times now, his advice is probably pretty sound for the paycheck to paycheck buried in CC debt demographic that unfortunately so many Americans fall in. But there are certain circumstances when you can take his advice and ignore it.
Forget my situation. Since I’m a car guy so of course I’m going to prioritize more money for cars. Ramsey would try to have me locked up having two cars that equal about double my annual income. Even though I didn’t buy them with money from my actual job, it’s still probably a bit excessive I’ll admit. But again, I’m a car guy. If I didn’t have a wife who wanted me to buy other shit like $10k mattresses and new plates and utensils from Crate & Barrel(not even sure what that costs yet but I’m sure it won’t be cheap), I’d probably be spending even more money on cars because I’d live in some funky one bedroom studio type place with a cheap Casper mattress and a single spork in the kitchenette…but has a 8 car garage.
But how about my 72 year old mother? She’s been fine with less than $40k a year from SSI and is actually pissed that she’s at the age where she has to start withdrawing from her 401k (was happy last year because she didn’t have to). So according to Ramsey, she should be rolling in a $18k lightly used Corolla or something along those lines because her “income” dictates that, even though she has the savings to buy much more than that in cash? Yeah I’m not seeing my mom in her golden years holding back on not having a nice car. She gets to drive whatever makes her happy.