What do you guys think about the options provided by the cottage industry that's sprung up around dealing with press-fit BBs? More specifically...
I have a PF30 carbon endurance frame with a cheap heavy FSA 30mm crankset and a cheap BB that pings under power. I'd like to chuck the whole lot and run Ultegra cranks.
From what I have seen thus far, the options are:
1) Wheels Mfg adapter PF30 -> Shimano 24mm. Alloy construction, the cups screw together in the BB shell, 2437 Enduro bearings, also available in angular contact or ceramic.
2) Praxis Works adapter PF30 -> Shimano 24mm, similar idea but one of the cups behaves as a collet in the BB shell when the other cup is screwed in, potentially providing a more secure fit. Ceramic bearing upgrade option, but no angular IIRC.
3) BBinfinite adapter PF30 -> Shimano 24mm. One piece alloy unit pressed into BB shell; good bearings. Removal of unit, should that be required down the road, seems like a bitch. They sell an air hammer adapter for that purpose. Cool-aid factor prominent in their marketing.
4) Plastic press-fit SRAM PF30 -> BSA adapters. Thereafter can run native Ultegra cups with 6805 bearings, etc. I am worried that this would entail replacing one type of press-fit plastic crappiness with another.
5) FSA alloy PF30 -> BSA adapter. One piece construction like BBinfinite but with BSA threads instead of pressed-in bearings. I almost like this as the improvement over 4), but can't get over the stupidity of having to press in a big chunk of metal just to get back to a normal BSA thread situation. Where's your weight savings now, PF30 "standard"?
6) Enduro Bearings makes a more expensive unit very similar to Wheels Mfg. Two piece screw-together alloy construction, non-collet.
7) Quality native PF30 BB like Chris King. Diameter reducers would be needed for the 24mm spindle. CK seems to want the shell to be reamed out to exact spec beforehand. I can imagine there still being a creaking issue with some fit deficiency between the alloy CK cups and the shell, though the bearings themselves would be beyond reproach.
8) Parlee PF30 -> Shimano 24mm alloy cups. No reducers needed, but concerns about a purely press-fit arrangement remain.
That's about it, off the top of my head. If you have feedback on the relative merits of these or other approaches, a grateful nation awaits your post.
p.s. 9) KCNC PF30 -> Shimano 24mm adapter. This is a screw-together two piece non-collet alloy unit like Wheels Mfg and Enduro, but unlike the array of 24mm ID 2437 bearing options Wheels / Enduro offers, these guys use 25mm ID 6805 bearings just like Shimano, with a plastic Shimano-style insert that ends up doing the 25mm -> 24mm reduction. RWC are offering this unit with various grades of 2437 bearings pressed in.